Earnestly searching for an emotional anchor in her turbulent career, Sridevi settled for already-married Boney Kapoor, and they bore two daughters, Janvi and Khushi
I did not know Sridevi, though she and I share the date (if not the year) of our birth. I never met her even once during a 2-decade career as a film journalist with STARDUST magazine (which typically named her ‘thunder thighs’ in its irrepressible, incomparable Neeta’s Natter).
However, I had very close encounters and precious relationships with others listed in the category of actors she belonged to. Category: leading Bollywood women whose lives entangled with a married man with adoring wife and children.
Hema Malini, Rekha, Sarika, Sridevi, Zeenat Aman, Shabana Azmi, Smita Patil, to name just a few of them.
I have been with some of them through poignant personal situations, and firsthand I can report that the one thing they have in common is a warm and loving heart, which simply yearned for a resting place for their spirit from very early in their lives. That is why each made the decision she did. This reflection in this blog is not on the women but on their parents.
We need to look at the Big Picture.
Dysfunctional Background…
Most of those mentioned came from a dysfunctional background, and were thrust into the film industry long before puberty; Sridevi when she was barely four. Due to having to see to several other children, Rekha’s mother launched her in the Hindi film industry, but could not be permanently around in Bombay to attend to her. She would leave her 13-14 year old child in hotels, in the care of specially assigned waiters that they would look after Rekha like she was their own daughter. I leave you to imagine how they cared for her.
It is very possible that far from being greedy and exploitative, the parents in question recognized they’d birthed a child prodigy. In fact, some of the parents endeavored to give the child a ‘normal upbringing’ by bringing in tutors to keep her on level with academics. Others kept a hawk-like vigilant eye to ensure there was no ‘hanky panky’ stuff happening behind the scenes.
Major lack and slack…
The one thing that was lacking in the lives of these women was a moral upbringing. They got expertise in how to handle roles, producers, fans, financial transactions, and a host of other things. What happened to morals and values? The Cambridge dictionary emphasizes that a moral upbringing is one in which “you are treated and educated when young, especially by your parents, especially in relation to the effect that this has on how you behave and make moral decisions.”
What moral principles reigned in their respective families?
Baby Sarika blindly obeyed her mother
Domineering Mother…
Zeenat, Rekha, Sarika – grew up without a father in the house which left within them an eternal ache for those important under-girding, everlasting arms of God’s earthly representative in a home. They got into relationships early in life not because they were promiscuous but because of a craving for those missing arms. Rekha’s famous father, Gemini Ganesan, did not even acknowledge she was his daughter until she became a superstar herself. As infants, we take in a
South Indian actor Gemini Ganesan finally acknowledges Bollywood star Rekha as his daughter
complete sensory experience of our everyday surroundings and this shapes our perception of normalcy, I am sure we do not need the Journal of Genetic Psychology to show the influence of father on daughter’s relationships with other men in her life. Our parents shape and color the lens through which we see and organize meaning about other human interactions, of what we can expect, and what is acceptable in a romantic partner.
God’s created order of man first, never intended a woman to be head of the family. God could have made a woman as physically strong as a man; He did not do so for a reason. The man had to be breadwinner and protector of his wife and children; whereas women are to leave all else and focus on keeping the children on the right track. Whenever roles were reversed, there has been the inevitable imbalance.
In Hema Malini and Sridevi’s cases, there was a father somewhere in the background; kept firmly there by a domineering mother who met producers and demanded exorbitant prices for the daughter’s signing the dotted line for a film. Would you blame the daughter’s distaste for the goings-on related to her career, and longing for a way out; add this to the already-existent thirst for the missing arms of an abdicating father. Undiluted vulnerability!
Hema Malini liked (best actor in the Indian subcontinent) Sanjeev Kumar, may have even married him, but her Amma said No. Mrs. Chakravorthy wanted her daughter to enjoy more of her career success.
Only later, when she found Hema getting involved with Dharmendra, did Amma tell me, in private, to convey to Sanjeev that it was Amma and not Hema who had said No, and that Amma was now ready to consider his proposal. When I passed on the whispered message to Sanjeev, he gave me a look that would have annihilated me if he had not toned it down in consideration of my eighth-month pregnant state at that time. By then, the world knew Hema and Dharmendra were seriously involved.
The ones who bear the brunt …
Dharmendra and Hema Malini married in 1979 under Islamic laws. They had an Iyengar ceremony too on May 2, 1980.
After a lot of family opposition, Hema Malini became the second wife of father-of-four, Dharmendra, in 1980, after converting to Islam. Hema became Aisha Bi R. Chakravarthy and Dharam became Dilawar Khan Kewal Krishn. In an attempt to get public acceptance, the Chakravorthys organized a Hindu ceremony too. Hema was thrilled to have two daughters Esha and Ahana … and continued to love them unconditionally, even though both reportedly survived adolescence only due to chemical dependence. Finally, they married businessmen who came in from the cold.
That is the problem – because of their own impeded background, the women made their sanity-saving choices, not realizing that one day, their children would bear the consequences of their decision.
Smita’s son Prateik is finding it enormously difficult to get a grip on his life
Prateik Babbar, who lost his mother actress Smita Patil, a few days after his birth in 1986, suffered more than the other children-of-the-second-wife-syndrome. Hear his pain in his own words: ”My first real drug was a disturbed childhood. Constantly faced with internal dilemma, and the (unrelenting) voices in my head debating who I am and where I belong, drugs came as a welcomed escape. I got acquainted with the narcotic underbelly, which led me to my first run-in with drugs when I was 13.”
After going into serious rehab, he has now been clean for over a year, but still alert to the enemy within. “I am certain that I will wrestle my need for drugs even on my best days, but the only way to keep cynicism at bay is by sharing the emotions that fueled my addiction in the first place.”
Throwing wisdom to the winds…
In Shabana’s case, at least there are no children from her side to consider (the adult children from his side and first wife Honey, went through hell as they can tell you).
She married Javed despite her better judgment – Shabana takes the plunge
I am surprised Shabana Azmi made the decision she did with regard to Javed Akhtar. Her poet, philosopher, mentor father, Kaifi Azmi, did not even believe fully in marriage, and went to the extent of prophesying (in an exclusive interview with this writer) a day would come when the institution of marriage would be wiped out, and children would be “the responsibility of the state.” When Shabana and Javed began to get involved, she informed her father, and asked him, “Is he (Javed) wrong for me?” Kaifi said, “He is not wrong, but the circumstances are wrong.” To that, she asked her father, “What if I change the circumstances?” Kaifi Azmi said,” Then it will be okay.”
Despite that, Shabana agonized for many seasons over her decision. Despite their being screen rivals, she had met Smita Patil after the latter married Raj Babbar. She got a firsthand report of how torturous the situation is when there is a first wife still alive, and children to consider. I met her once at her quaint and lovely place Janki Kutir, at our pre-arranged time of 7.30 AM and found her in total disarray. Javed and she had been walking the whole night on Juhu Beach trying to sort out the dilemma of their relationship. I asked her what she was going to do. She put her hands in her head and said, “I don’t think I can go ahead with it. There is too much suffering involved. I can’t go through what Smita is going through.”
Ultimately, her emotions got the better of her. Since Javed had reportedly had an irreversible operation, there was no question of children. Sad that a brilliant actor of Shabana’s caliber leaves us with no legacy of a child who could take forward her brilliant talent.
O Sridevi…
Let’s get back to where we started out – the actor of the hour, the queen of our hurting hearts, Sridevi.
A great actress, a warm and shy human being – Sridevi was the best, no two opinions
India (if the prime news channels can be said to reflect the country) stood still for the days following the unexpected death, as her mortal remains were withheld by the authorities in Dubai where she passed away in not an ordinary situation. Every channel and newspaper hailed her as India’s first superstar, packed with talent that put her head and lovely shoulders above every other Bollywood heroine of her generation.
They are 200% correct, that is beyond debate.
Like every actress named above, Sridevi too was a good girl in every sense of the word – loyal to her parents, faithful to her craft, and her work. When she and Mithun Chakraborty got romantically drawn to each other, it had nothing to do with an affair, or a fling. She really wanted to marry him and make a home for him and settle down. And he, with her. Only problem is he was already married to Yogita, and they were parenting three really cute children. Yogita, who is as sweet and naïve as they come, said, “I will not leave my husband whatever he does, I will always be his wife; he can take on a second wife if he wants, I will not object.”
That sealed the matter, as far as Mithun was concerned. The relationship with Sridevi was switched off with immediate effect, and first husband and first wife had a fourth child to seal their marriage forever.
In Boney Kapoor’s case, he was the one who pursued Sridevi. She resisted, but then suddenly, her father died, and during those heartbroken days, Boney showed up in trumps, and that pulled the rug out of her resistance. He coaxed his wife Mona that they needed to show kindness to Sridevi in her hour of need, and even brought her to live in his home. Mona permitted it because she was told Sridevi once tied a raakhi on Boney Kapoor and the wife believed that to be their relationship until the husband finally revealed he was in love with Sridevi.
The rest is history. The lesson to learn is that the home, and marriage space, is a sacred sanctuary, which should never allow a third person of either gender into its holy territory. It does not make God happy. It allows elements from evil quarters to enter the scene to devour.
Why bring it up now?
If not now, then when? When ‘love stories’ are crested in stone, etching them out to be inspirational duets (to romantic generations that follow) ?… which they are not. If Nargis Dutt were alive, she would testify how after the Hema-Dharam marriage in 1980, MP Mrs. Dutt was accosted in Parliament by other MPs who demanded from her an explanation on the Dharmendra-Hema marriage and the bad effect it would have on the nation by inspiring middle-class movie star worshippers to emulate their favorite couple. Before she could investigate to reply to Parliament, Nargis was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer, and she died a year later.
(A suggestion: Can our current Prime Minister use his Aadhaar network to find out how many middle class couples, in the year 1980, had men taking on second wives or sweethearts, damning the consequences, and impacting their children forever (who in turn, will do things that will subsequently impact their children and the generations that follow). There were thousands! I was a columnist in MID-DAY at that time and had a firsthand news byte from the newspaper that one of the staff members had married his wife’s younger sister, and brought her to live in the home with his first wife and children.)
Hema on the warpath…
It was with all that in mind, many years ago, I spoke to Ms. Malini, when we met in the beautiful bungalow she lived in with her two school-going daughters. The meeting was to discuss her becoming the next SAVVY Woman of the Month – it was a pedestal (first person, beginning to end) the magazine accorded to a woman who can change life for the better of other women in India. Hema got the mistaken notion that the magazine would project her as a woman who has ‘eaten her cake and has it too’. (The proverb actually means you cannot simultaneously retain your cake and eat it too, and means that one cannot or should not try to have two incompatible things at the same time.)
She was flabbergasted when I informed her that we would only carry her “I Believe” (the title name of the feature) if the ‘hook’ of the story would see her admitting that she had made a mistake by marrying a married man, and she would advise other women in the country to never make the same error. She was furious, and said she did not think it was a mistake. I said it may appear she has got away with it, but pointed her to Smita Patil, and several other film as well as middle-class persons who were suffering the consequences of following in the Hema-Dharam footsteps.
She tilted her nose upwards in that style that is typically Malini, and said stubbornly, “I did what was right for me.” Then sorry, there would be no cover, no story. At least not during my tenure. The journalist who accompanied me, was shocked by my stand because she felt a story would be a story no matter what the celebrity came out with.
That, I would say, is what has gone wrong with the world. Commerce is rated higher than Morality in particular with the media.
In conclusion …
All the women in this article, I repeat, were decent girls, with character, and commitment, and would have made A-1+ wives to first-time husbands. However, due to the emotional deprivation of their childhood, because of little moral upbringing and no true relationship with God encouraged, they made the decisions they did, and things worked out the way they have, in many cases, tragically.
The Kamal Hassan-Vani Ganpathi marriage broke up when Sarika came on the scene. Sarika took her liberation further: her daughter Shruti was born in 1986, out of marriage. So she married Kamal only after their second daughter Akshara was born five years later. She wanted both children to have the same birth status
Do you believe God created the world? Then you will note some traits of His character in the earth we live in: it’s a world of perfect order – day follows night, seasons follow each others, the sun never goes on strike, the earth is governed by natural laws.
Well, if God has been so particular and specific about the natural laws of the universe, imagine how stringent He is about the moral laws that govern the hearts lives of human beings who are created in His image and which have to be lived according to the divinely-inspired rules of civilization.
Twist the rules, and what is likely to happen?
I love the way novelist Wallace Stegner puts it in his novel, All the Little Live Things: “It is the beginning of wisdom when you recognize that the best you can do is choose which rules you want to live by.” He added: “It is persistent and aggravated imbecility to pretend you can live without any.”